Antigua Resort Comparison Tool

Buccaneer Beach Club

Buccaneer Beach Club gets a lot of love from people who like small, unfussy places. Reviews often describe it as a “little gem” tucked at the quieter end of Dickenson Bay, with simple but practical apartments, a small pool and a gate that takes you straight onto the sand. Families and longer-stay guests appreciate having a proper kitchen, decent air con and easy access to the supermarket and local restaurants. Most feedback calls it good value and praises how well the grounds and rooms are kept. The negatives are more about expectations: the pool is small, the decor and kitchens are clearly dated, and a few guests have been frustrated by slow or inconsistent housekeeping and front-desk interactions. Noise from neighbours or the beach can also creep in, given the compact layout.

Siboney Beach Club

Siboney is usually described as a small, characterful boutique option on Dickenson Bay rather than a resort in the big-brand sense. Long-time fans talk about its lush gardens, intimate pool area, home-like suites with kitchenettes, and an owner and staff who make them feel part of the family. It attracts people who actively want to avoid large, corporate hotels and prefer something personal and low-key. Recent negative reviews, though, are blunt about the shortcomings: slow and sometimes surly service in the on-site restaurant, long waits for food and drinks, and a sense that parts of the property and service culture haven’t kept pace with expectations or price. So experiences vary sharply depending on what matters most to the guest.

Ocean Point Beach Resort & Spa

Reviews of Ocean Point usually land on it being a solid, no-frills, adult-focused hotel with an Italian flavour, rather than a glossy resort. Guests who enjoy it tend to mention the sea views, big central pool with plenty of loungers, decent mattresses and surprisingly good food in the main restaurant for the price point. Staff, especially in the bar and dining areas, get regular praise for being friendly and remembering repeat guests. On the flip side, plenty of people point out that the small cove-style beach isn’t the classic wide Antiguan stretch, and parts of the property feel worn around the edges – weeds through decking, tired furnishings and limited public spaces. Some reviewers also say the amenity set is quite basic for the rates being charged, so you need to go in expecting a comfortable three-star with good food, not a luxury all-inclusive.

Pineapple Beach Club Antigua

Reviews for Pineapple Beach Club are generally warm, especially from repeat guests who like its easygoing, adults-only atmosphere and pretty bay. People rave about the beach and calm, swimmable water, plus the fact there are several pools with plenty of loungers so it rarely feels like a “sunbed war”. Staff are often described as friendly and fun, and the nightly entertainment – steel bands, beach BBQs, quizzes – is a big part of the appeal. The food gets mixed but mostly decent feedback: the buffet at Topaz is often preferred over the à la cartes, with good variety but dishes not always piping hot. Rooms and buildings are clean but a bit dated in places, and a recurring niggle is the feeling of add-on costs and rising prices, which make some guests question value.

Jolly Beach Antigua

Jolly Beach is very much a “you get what you pay for” all-inclusive, and most reviewers go in with that mindset. The standout positive, almost universally, is the beach – a long, wide stretch of sand and a big main pool that between them soak up the crowds nicely. Guests also highlight friendly bar and restaurant staff and say that, when it’s running smoothly, the value for money is hard to beat. Where the resort struggles is age and upkeep: a lot of feedback mentions rooms that feel like they haven’t seen a proper refurb in decades, tired public areas and basic amenities. Food and drink are described as acceptable but rarely more than that, and Wi‑Fi and maintenance issues crop up regularly in recent comments.

Antigua Village Beach Resort

Antigua Village gets very strong recent feedback for its location and staff. Guests love being right on Dickenson Bay with easy access to the beach, nearby restaurants and water activities, while still having the flexibility of condo-style units with kitchens. Reviews repeatedly mention how clean the units are, how friendly and helpful the team is, and how peaceful the pool and gardens feel. Many rate it as great value for money and come back year after year. On the downside, even happy guests note that some apartments are dated and in need of refreshed bathrooms or décor; the condo model means quality varies a bit by individual owner, and a few people have been disappointed where the unit didn’t match photos.

The Escape at Nonsuch Bay

The Escape at Nonsuch Bay gets a lot of enthusiastic write-ups from guests who want a quiet, adults-only bubble. People love the large suites with proper plunge pools and big sea views, plus a main pool and bar area that stays calm even when the hotel is full. Reviews highlight genuinely friendly staff, a boutique feel and thoughtful touches like complimentary massages or well-presented floating breakfasts, which make it feel special. Many rate the food highly, especially themed nights and local dishes, and say the whole place matches the photos. At the same time, there are some sharp negative reviews: complaints about limited snacks between mealtimes, repetitive or under-seasoned dishes, a very sleepy atmosphere in the evenings, and practical issues like mosquitos, patchy Wi‑Fi or small maintenance oversights. The remote location also means taxi costs add up if you like to eat or drink out.

St James’s Club & Villas

St James’s Club divides opinion. Many guests like the twin-bay setting, range of pools and activities, and the fact it works for both families and couples. It’s often recommended in forums as a “solid” all-inclusive with lots going on. At the same time, critics – and there are plenty – complain about dated rooms, patchy maintenance and food that’s firmly average, with only one or two restaurants getting consistent praise. Comments about poor management, overworked staff and surcharges or limited menus crop up regularly, especially from those expecting a true 4-star+ experience.

Keyonna Beach Resort

Keyonna comes up again and again as a laid-back, adults-only, toes-in-the-sand escape that feels more rustic than polished. Guests love the quiet beach, assigned Bali beds, the sense of privacy and the fact it rarely feels crowded; some say it feels like having your own stretch of Antigua to yourselves. Staff often get named shout-outs for being kind and going out of their way, and many reviewers rate the cooked-to-order food very highly. On the flip side, plenty of people mention that the style is “weathered” rather than luxe, with simple finishes and outdoor showers that rarely get truly hot. Service can be slow and “island-time”, and mosquitos are a recurring theme, even though spray is provided.

Cocobay Resort

Cocobay tends to win people over with its views first. Perched on a hillside above two small beaches, it feels peaceful and grown-up, with pastel cottages, hammocks and those photogenic plunge pools looking straight over the water. Guests talk about how romantic it feels once you’re actually there – fairy lights along the paths at night, outdoor baths, quiet pools and very little in the way of forced entertainment. Service and cocktails are generally well liked, and most recent reviewers say they left feeling properly switched off. On the downside, you see repeated comments about the beach not being quite as picture-perfect as some Antigua postcards, occasional maintenance niggles with plunge pools or room fittings, and a food offering that’s good but not endlessly varied, especially if you stay more than a week.

Curtain Bluff

Curtain Bluff is widely praised by repeat guests as a low-key, traditional luxury all-inclusive with very strong service, lots of included activities and a high percentage of returning visitors. Reviews highlight friendly staff, great included water sports (water-skiing, tubing, snorkelling, even scuba), good gym and a relaxed but upmarket feel. Many call it one of the best hotels on Antigua and particularly like the community feel and lack of nickel-and-diming. Criticisms focus on food being good but sometimes repetitive or a little old-fashioned, some rooms needing refurbishment, and beaches where entry can be tricky due to rocks on one side. Noise from neighbouring families/children in adjoining rooms occasionally bothers couples seeking total tranquillity.

Royalton Antigua

Royalton Antigua reviews are mixed but generally show a modern, feature-rich family resort with good facilities but variable service. Guests like the stylish rooms, multiple restaurants and bars, kids’ club, foam parties and entertainment, plus overwater bungalows for splurge stays. Families appreciate the variety of activities and overall energy. However, several reviews and discussions note inconsistent service, queues at restaurants, sometimes average food quality and occasional maintenance and cleanliness issues. Some travellers also feel the resort can get crowded and noisy, which may not suit those seeking peace.

Hawksbill Resort Antigua

Hawksbill is the classic “love it if it’s your style” resort. Reviews talk about four gorgeous, quiet beaches, big sea views and a very low-key, old-school Caribbean feel. Many guests emphasise how peaceful it is – no blaring music, no TVs in most rooms, and a mostly adult crowd who come to read, swim and chat rather than party. Staff are frequently described as warm and genuine, and a lot of reviewers highlight the value for money compared with more polished all-inclusive brands. On the negative side, even fans admit it’s rustic: simple rooms, basic bathrooms and mattresses that some find uncomfortable, with décor a long way from contemporary luxury. Food is generally “fine” rather than fancy, and there are the usual bug comments you’d expect from such a natural setting.

The Verandah Resort & Spa

Reviews of The Verandah show a resort with strong repeat business that many guests enjoy for its value, views and relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere, but with very mixed feedback on food and service. People like the spacious grounds, cove-style beaches, mini-golf, pools and the fact it works well for multi-generational trips. Staff are often described as friendly, and all-inclusive pricing can be attractive versus more upscale options. On the negative side, food is a frequent complaint: menus and snacks are seen as limited or repetitive, some dishes are described as poor quality, and restaurant booking systems frustrate guests when venues appear half-empty but show as “fully booked”. Service and maintenance can also be patchy, with comments about tired rooms, weak snacks and not enough transport around the hilly property.

Sandals Grande Antigua

Guests largely review Sandals Grande Antigua as a classic couples-only, honeymoon-friendly resort on one of the island’s best beaches, Dickenson Bay. People like the romantic feel, big pool, multiple restaurants and bars, and the split between the livelier Mediterranean side and more lush, “traditional Caribbean” village side. Many honeymooners call it a great trip with beautiful grounds and plenty to do. On the downside, reviews repeatedly mention slow service at bars and restaurants, the need to reserve pool spots early, and “island-time” pacing that can frustrate guests expecting fast, American-style efficiency. Some also mention mosquitos after dark and occasional room/maintenance niggles or dated areas versus newer Sandals resorts.

Royalton CHIC Antigua

Royalton CHIC reviews highlight a very modern, stylish adults-only all-inclusive with attractive pools, a good beach and lively entertainment. Guests often praise the newness of the property, clean rooms, friendly staff, and fun atmosphere with parties, music and multiple bars and restaurants. Many reviewers say they had a great time and would return, especially appreciating the pools, landscaping and overall vibe.

However, there is a clear pattern of complaints: inconsistent service, difficulty booking à la carte restaurants via the app, average or repetitive food, and operational teething issues like housekeeping inconsistency or poorly maintained public bathrooms. Some online discussions also mention more serious dissatisfaction with management responsiveness and food quality.

Cocos Hotel

Reviews paint COCOS as a rustic-luxury, adults-only clifftop hideaway with big sea views and strong romantic appeal. Guests love the intimate scale, super-friendly staff, hammocks and outdoor showers, plus access to two beaches with free kayaks and snorkelling gear. The vibe is very relaxed and barefoot, with no TVs in most rooms and an emphasis on downtime over nightlife. Food is generally described as tasty and à la carte, but there is repeated feedback that menus are short and portions on the small side, which can get repetitive on longer stays.

Hammock Cove Antigua

Reviews describe Hammock Cove as an ultra-luxury, adults-only boutique resort with huge villas, private plunge pools and exceptionally attentive but unobtrusive service. Food is repeatedly called fine-dining quality, with many guests saying it is some of the best they have had in the Caribbean, especially at Lighthouse and the beach BBQs. The setting is quiet and romantic, overlooking a small cove near Devil’s Bridge, with strong praise for peaceful ambience and well-kept pools and beach.

Blue Waters Resort & Spa

Blue Waters is reviewed as a beautiful, established luxury resort with lush gardens, multiple pools and small coves that work very well for families and couples alike. Guests frequently praise the friendly staff, kid-friendly vibe, good choice of restaurants and attractive, well-kept grounds. Many families call it “great for kids” and love the relaxed but upmarket feel. However, a persistent theme in recent reviews is inconsistency: some meals and restaurants are excellent while others disappoint, and service can swing from outstanding to slow or disorganised, especially at busy times. Price/value occasionally comes up, with some guests feeling standards do not always match 5-star pricing.

Carlisle Bay

Carlisle Bay is often reviewed as a stylish, contemporary beach resort that works especially well for families, thanks to its kids’ club, calm bay and spacious suites. Guests like the setting, views, and overall facilities, and many families highlight how much their children enjoy the pool, beach and kids’ activities. However, there is a recurring theme that service can be hit-and-miss for a supposed 5-star: slow or irregular beach and pool service, inconsistent housekeeping, and various small maintenance or room issues that feel out of place at this level. Some reviewers also mention beds and linens being less comfortable than expected and frustration around billing extras such as bottled water on all-inclusive plans.

Galley Bay Resort & Spa

Reviews consistently describe Galley Bay as a serene, adults-oriented, mostly couples resort with a superb beach and very high guest loyalty. Many guests return repeatedly, citing friendly staff who remember names, an intimate layout, and a peaceful, “ocean-paradise” feel with rooms steps from the sand. The all-inclusive food and cocktails are generally rated highly, and people enjoy activities like yoga, tennis and snorkelling without the resort ever feeling crowded. Some comments mention bugs (especially sandflies/no-see-ums in certain seasons), and a few feel décor in some rooms is slightly dated versus newer ultra-luxury hotels.

Hermitage Bay

Hermitage Bay reviews are extremely positive, often calling it one of the best resorts guests have ever stayed in. The resort is praised for its secluded bay, lush hillside setting and ultra-private villa suites, many with plunge pools and exceptional sunset views. Service is described as genuinely caring but not intrusive, with staff remembered fondly by name and a strong focus on “zero-stress” relaxation. Food quality is widely rated as excellent, and the spa, yoga decks and wellness atmosphere get special mention. Downsides are mainly practical: steep steps or hills to hillside suites, premium pricing, and occasional bug bites at dusk despite resort efforts.

Jumby Bay Island

Jumby Bay is reviewed as a true “private island bubble” – ultra‑luxury, quiet and polished, with a long, soft beach and calm, clear water that guests rave about. Families and couples talk about how easy everything feels once they arrive: seamless VIP transfers, staff who quickly learn names, and a setting where bikes, buggies and barefoot walks replace cars. The all‑inclusive aspect is generally described as very high quality, with standout breakfasts, beach service that just appears when you want it, and thoughtful touches like kids’ activities, a small farm and nature experiences. At the same time, a minority of recent reviewers flag that not everything is perfect at the price point: food can occasionally miss the mark, some indoor spaces like the gym or spa changing areas feel underwhelming or small, and retail and spa pricing is called out as eye‑wateringly high even by luxury standards. A few guests also felt overall service, while kind, was not consistently five‑star for what they paid.